Bay Island Homes with Beach Access Water Frontage

Bay Island Homes with Beach Access Water Frontage

Welcome to Bay Island, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Siesta Key, Florida. This enchanting subdivision is renowned for its stunning waterfront properties and unparalleled access to the pristine beaches that make Siesta Key a premier destination. With a vibrant community atmosphere and breathtaking views, Bay Island offers a tranquil escape for those seeking the perfect blend of relaxation and adventure.

The homes in Bay Island are designed with coastal living in mind, featuring exquisite architecture that complements the natural beauty of the surrounding environment. Many residences boast direct beach access, allowing you to step out of your door and onto the soft, powdery sands that Siesta Key is famous for. Whether you’re looking for a charming bungalow or a luxurious waterfront estate, Bay Island has something to suit every taste and lifestyle.

Imagine waking up to the gentle sound of waves lapping against the shore, enjoying morning coffee on your private deck, or hosting family gatherings with stunning sunset views over the Gulf of Mexico. With water frontage as a hallmark of this subdivision, residents can indulge in a variety of water activities, from paddleboarding and kayaking to fishing and boating.

Bay Island is not just a place to live; it’s a lifestyle. With a close-knit community, nearby dining, shopping, and recreational opportunities, you’ll find everything you need within easy reach. Embrace the coastal charm and vibrant lifestyle of Bay Island, where beach access and waterfront living come together to create a paradise you’ll be proud to call home.

Newest Bay Island Homes with Beach Access Water Frontage

3482 Flamingo Avenue, Sarasota
$6,975,000
6 Beds ⋅ 7 Baths ⋅ Bay Island SubDv. ⋅ 34242 Zip Code
Some homes are defined by their architecture, others by their setting. Casa Flamingo is a rare convergence of both, offering a distinctive vision of waterfront living on the coveted north end of Siesta Key. Set across nearly an acre of lush grounds, this custom-built estate encompasses nearly 10,000sqft of total space, ideal for multi-generational living. Beyond the gated entrance, a palm-lined drive passes beneath the guest house’s striking arched passageway, opening to a courtyard where hand-carved Cantera stone introduces the shimmering waters of a 45-ft long pool. The grounds unfold toward the waterfront, where white sand creates a private beach-like retreat, complete with a launch for kayaking and a private dock and lift. Along the protected waters of Hanson Bayou, deep-water boating offers effortless access to the Gulf of Mexico without fixed bridges. Here, outdoor living takes on an entirely different dimension, with spaces designed for leisurely afternoons and sunset gatherings. The main residence centers around an expansive great room and chef’s kitchen, complemented by an expansive primary suite and additional guest accommodations. Elevated above the entrance, the separate guest house offers a private retreat for family and guests. Completing the estate is an oversized 3-car garage. From the private dock, Sarasota Bay, Big Pass, and the open Gulf become an extension of everyday life. Casa Flamingo offers a rare opportunity to experience the north end of Siesta Key, with Sarasota’s celebrated dining, cultural destinations, and boutique shopping just moments away.

3482 Flamingo Avenue, Sarasota

546 Freeling Drive, Sarasota
$12,500,000
5 Beds ⋅ 7 Baths ⋅ Bay Island SubDv. ⋅ 34242 Zip Code
Pre-Construction. To be built. Expected to be complete in 3–4 months. Discover an extraordinary opportunity to own a new construction waterfront residence on an expansive 0.52-acre double lot on North Siesta Key. Designed and built by Pham Development, this single-story, transitional modern-style home offers 170 feet of deep-water canal frontage, 4,353 square feet under air, and 15,453 square feet under roof. Featuring 5 bedrooms, 5 full bathrooms, 2 half baths, a designated private office, and the option for a private fitness studio, the residence showcases soaring 17.5-foot vaulted ceilings, a striking glass wine wall, and designer finishes. Light-filled interiors capture tranquil water views, while lush landscaping across the canal—with no homes visible—creates a serene, private backdrop. Opportunities to customize finishes and style allow you to make the home your own. Designed for both everyday comfort and entertaining, the open-concept living spaces center around a chef’s kitchen featuring a 72-inch Sub-Zero refrigerator, Cove dishwasher, and Wolf range, coffee maker, and microwave. The living areas flow seamlessly onto an expansive back patio equipped with remote-controlled electric mosquito screens, allowing you to enclose the space at the touch of a button. A spectacular pool with a champagne hot tub spa, generous outdoor lounging areas, and a fully equipped Wolf outdoor kitchen create an inviting setting for alfresco dining and waterfront entertaining. The primary suite offers a private sanctuary with spa-inspired amenities and thoughtfully designed personal spaces. An elegant circular driveway creates a grand arrival, while the expansive ground level offers room for up to 10 cars, complemented by an impressive 10-car garage—ideal for collectors or additional storage. Combining exceptional canal frontage, peaceful views, and beautifully appointed indoor and outdoor spaces, this distinctive North Siesta Key residence offers refined coastal living.

546 Freeling Drive, Sarasota

609 Norsota Way, Sarasota
$8,500,000
Bay Island SubDv. ⋅ 34242 Zip Code
An extraordinary opportunity to create a custom waterfront estate on coveted Norsota Way, where spectacular panoramic views stretch across Sarasota Bay to the downtown skyline and Ringling Bridge. Positioned on an exceptional 0.57-acre homesite in the prestigious Bay Island neighborhood of Siesta Key, this rare property offers an impressive 370 feet of combined water frontage, including approximately 168 feet directly on Sarasota Bay and 202 feet along the protected yacht basin. With expansive open-water views, a generous homesite, and exceptional boating access, this is a remarkable setting for a one-of-a-kind Sarasota waterfront residence. The property's distinctive configuration offers the best of both worlds: sweeping, unobstructed views across the open bay and the convenience of protected water frontage along the adjoining yacht basin. Boating enthusiasts will appreciate direct access to Sarasota Bay, the Intracoastal Waterway, and the Gulf of Mexico, with multiple waterways and destinations within easy reach. The extensive water frontage creates exceptional possibilities for designing a residence that embraces Sarasota's boating lifestyle. Spanning approximately 25,040 square feet, the cleared homesite provides an expansive canvas for a thoughtfully designed custom estate. Its generous dimensions and remarkable waterfront setting offer opportunities to incorporate substantial indoor and outdoor living spaces, expansive terraces, a resort-style pool, and beautifully landscaped grounds. Imagine walls of glass framing panoramic bay views, generous entertaining areas overlooking the water, and a private outdoor retreat designed around Sarasota's spectacular coastal scenery. The property's concrete seawall, irrigation well, and available public utilities add to its appeal as a premier waterfront building opportunity. Located on coveted Norsota Way within the established Bay Island neighborhood, the property is just moments from the mainland and the beaches of Siesta Key. This distinctive waterfront enclave is known for its beautiful homes, mature landscaping, and convenient access to Sarasota's finest amenities. Enjoy nearby Southside Village, with its popular restaurants, boutiques, and neighborhood charm, as well as convenient access to Sarasota Memorial Hospital, Marie Selby Botanical Gardens, and Downtown Sarasota's vibrant dining, shopping, theaters, galleries, and cultural attractions. The world-renowned white sands of Siesta Key Beach, Siesta Key Village, and Sarasota's picturesque bayfront are also just a short drive away.

609 Norsota Way, Sarasota

Start Your Search

How much is your home worth?

Get instant property value now!